Donovan Mitchell committed his future to the Cleveland Cavaliers. The team was poised to offer him a four-year, $273 million contract extension that would keep him in Cleveland through 2031, and he was set to sign it, even though waiting until next summer could have earned him an additional $80 million.

The timing gave Mitchell a welcome reason to celebrate. In early July, he and singer Coco Jones gathered with their friends for a joint bachelor-bachelorette party before their wedding in August at a private residence in upstate New York. Seven groomsmen and six bridesmaids joined the couple, and during the trip, Mitchell and Jones took a moment for themselves. They knew their future was together, and now Mitchell was ready to settle where they would build it.

For years, Mitchell had said how much he loved the team and the city. He did not want a lingering contract negotiation to hang over the 2026-27 season. He wanted to make the commitment.

“The summer of celebrations,” Mitchell said.

The summer followed a spring of disappointment. For the first time in his career, Mitchell advanced to the conference finals after making the playoffs in each of his first nine seasons. The Cavs survived a seven-game first-round series against the Toronto Raptors, then won a Game 7 on the road against the top-seeded Detroit Pistons. Mitchell saw that run as a sign of growth, proof that the team was finally ready for whatever adversity came next. It was Cleveland’s deepest postseason run without LeBron James in 34 years.

An embarrassing sweep at the hands of the eventual champion New York Knicks ended the 2026 playoff run and left Cleveland with a losing postseason record overall, at 8-10. A familiar feeling settled over the franchise.

“In the moment it kind of leaves a sour taste in your mouth,” Mitchell said. “But as you sit … you have to realize, OK, you’ve done something you haven’t done before. OK. Now that’s great, but I wouldn’t call it an accomplishment. I would just call it a step.”

In Mitchell’s four seasons in Cleveland, the Cavs have consistently ranked among the top teams in the Eastern Conference, winning 51, 48, 64 and 52 games. The pattern has been clear: a dominant regular season followed by a playoff disappointment.

A Season of Continuity and Doubt

As the Cavaliers entered another offseason with the same core, the Eastern Conference landscape shifted around them. Rumors of a homecoming with James circulated across the organization and the league, but James chose Philadelphia. In response, Cleveland bet on continuity and on changes along the margins.

Sources said the Cavs were not interested in trading forward Evan Mobley, who is on a max rookie contract. After acquiring former MVP James Harden at last February’s trade deadline, the team re-signed the 37-year-old to a new three-year contract. One day after the season ended, the team also quieted speculation about the future of coach Kenny Atkinson.

Then Mitchell cemented his commitment.

“When doubt lingers in an organization, it’s not great,” Atkinson said. “Everybody’s just unsettled. So, the fact that Don locked it up, that was huge. It’s like a sigh of relief. You know you’re going to have your leader and it’s going to give you stability. It helps you just move forward quicker.”

The Cavs’ biggest move was acquiring wing Peyton Watson to serve as a fifth starter and help protect Mitchell and Harden on defense. So far, that bet has not paid off. Cleveland’s starting lineup has a minus-12.0 NET rating this season, and only the starters for Phoenix and Utah have been worse.

The start mirrors the team’s underwhelming season. Cleveland is 6-6, and skeptics around the league wonder why this year would be any different from the Cavs teams that came up short in years past.

Mitchell made his commitment because he believes in this group. He also knows that franchises, and especially their superstars, are not judged by participation trophies.

“For your own mental [health], you have to embrace it and then be proud of that,” he said. “In the same token, still keep the motivation of, ‘You got your a- swept.'”

Turning Criticism Into Jokes

Each summer, Mitchell hosts a basketball camp in Greenwich, Connecticut. For seven of the nine summers since he entered the NBA, he has spent a weekend running the event for kids from first grade through eighth grade, first in Utah and now in Cleveland. He always returns to the tristate area, where he grew up while his father worked for the New York Mets.

During this offseason’s camp, Mitchell knew the jokes were coming, and many of them centered on the Cavs’ dramatic loss to the Knicks in May. The punchline traced back to Atkinson. Before Game 4 of the conference finals, Atkinson said the Cavs were “analytically winning the series” because expected shot metrics showed Cleveland actually winning two of three games. In other words, the Knicks were making shots they were not supposed to make, and the Cavaliers were missing shots they were supposed to make.

“You get swept and you look the way we looked, there’s criticism and the jokes come with it,” Mitchell said. “We all laugh at it, but at the same time it’s like, all right, bet. Time’s going to come. But hey, you got to live with it. You got to live with all parts of it.”

Before a rematch with New York last week, Atkinson tried to add context to his comment. He said he was responding to a question about how the Cavs could still believe in themselves while trailing 3-0.

“I answered the question as it was taken,” Atkinson said. “‘You’re down 3-0, what hope do you have of even giving your guys?’ We get a lot of information, and I wasn’t lying in that sense. But in no sense was it like, ‘Oh man, we deserve to be winning.’ Zero, zero, zero thought of that.”

It is a familiar pattern for the Cavs, whose words often become the story instead of their play. After losing to the Knicks in the first round of the 2023 playoffs, Allen became a meme for saying “the lights were brighter than expected” after playing at Madison Square Garden.

“That’s the world we live in,” Cavs guard Sam Merrill said. “But we just have fun with stuff like that.”

The 2023 postseason was the first playoff run for Mitchell, Allen and Mobley. Cleveland reached the second round in each of the next two seasons before finally breaking through to the conference finals last spring. Despite that progress, skeptics around the league still point to the same throughline.

“All their questions will be answered in the playoffs,” an Eastern Conference executive said. “But it feels like they have the same issues that have plagued them for years. Not sure what’s going to be different.”

Learning From Another Sport

On the morning of Oct. 26, Atkinson chose an unusual approach to the team’s film session before the Cavs hosted the Minnesota Timberwolves that evening. Cleveland had already blown a 29-point lead against the Philadelphia 76ers on opening night, becoming the first team in league history to lose its opener after building a 20-point halftime lead. Two nights later, the Cavs saw a 22-point fourth-quarter lead against the Brooklyn Nets shrink to two with 8.1 seconds left, but they held on.

Those collapses revealed the doubt that has followed the team through the Mitchell era. In Game 1 of the conference finals, the Cavs led by 22 points at Madison Square Garden before collapsing in historic fashion.

Rather than review footage from the first few games or revisit the playoffs, Atkinson turned to a different sport. He had his players watch clips of the England vs. Argentina match from the FIFA World Cup semifinal this past July. England took a 1-0 lead in the 55th minute, then abruptly changed its approach and fell back into a defensive shape. Its aggression went cold, and the momentum shifted. Argentina rallied for a 2-1 victory and advanced to the final.

“[Kenny’s] just trying to find ways for it to stick in our head,” Cavs forward Jaylon Tyson said. “It worked.”

The Cavs put the lesson into practice that evening. They trailed by 15 in the second quarter and by double digits at halftime. After 15 lead changes and five ties in the final minutes, Cleveland survived a 47-point performance from Anthony Edwards and won in overtime, 127-125.

Inconsistency Continues

“There’s a lot of belief in this group,” Mitchell said. “And the way that we have been able to battle through some adversity and continue to get better and better.”

Even so, Cleveland’s inconsistency has persisted. The Cavs lost by double digits to the Charlotte Hornets on Monday, then bounced back to beat the Knicks at Madison Square Garden on Wednesday. No one embodies the team’s up-and-down season more than Harden, now in his 18th year, who was brought in to be Mitchell’s co-star. Harden is averaging 16.7 points and 5.6 assists while shooting 39% from the field, his lowest marks since he became a full-time starter during the 2012-13 season.

“My name is James Harden, and I used to score a lot of points,” Harden said after the Cavs’ victory in New York. “I still score points, but I’m finding other ways to impact the game as well.”

“I’m still trying to figure it out. Donovan averages a lot of points. He’s a scoring machine on this team. Just picking and choosing when I have opportunities to score and then do other things to impact winning.”

Despite the rocky start, Cleveland has reason for patience. The Cavs were one game over .500 on Dec. 19 last season, then won 52 games and secured the No. 4 seed.

Mitchell sees progress through the pain. He points to examples around the league that give him confidence in Cleveland’s approach, noting that New York lost in the second round twice and in the conference finals before winning the championship.

“People tend to forget those things,” he said. “How many teams were like, ‘Oh, it should be this. This guy needs to be traded. He needs to be fired.'”

“I’m not saying we’re guaranteed to win, but it’s just how it’s been. So we can’t sit here and overreact to everything just because everybody else thinks you should.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *